He came on strong in the beginning and was very affectionate, wanted to spend time with me, we were intimate etc (...) I started to notice a pattern of being ignored / getting the silent treatment every second week, particularly after being intimate (...) does the push pull method frequently... I know he has had fwb in the past and I realize that I've also become another one since we aren't "involved" exclusively.
So, I can tell you this doesn't sound like an Avoidant at all. He has no problem initiating a relationship and shows a lot of affection at first. I can tell you as an Avoidant that initiating a relationship is the worst of it all, because this means you have to approach someone, and it could perfectly be that the "target" doesn't like you, and then you bother them. That's why Avoidants don't initiate relationships! Also, I'm so dreadful of showing warm emotions that I sometimes struggle to say things like "thanks/you're welcome" and stuff like that even if it's imperative to say so in regards of puliteness.
It sounds like he's sexually exploiting you, and it sounds like this is his usual pattern of relating to others: he has had "friends with beenfits" before (if I decipher your shortening correctly), he ignores you after he got what he wanted, and, surprise, he's at a dating website, even though he's "involved" with you.
At one point i thought he was just a jerk that was using me, but I can tell that he's not, and there is more going on
Really? How do you tell? I see a lot in here that would definitely proof he doesn't give #+Q about you, but nothing that would proof else.
I have read a lot about attachment styles and he fits the avoidant to a T! I would be the anxious style, having trouble with the lack of affection.
Do you mean he has a dismissive-avoidant attachment style? Avoidants are usually anxious-avoidant as well. Dismissive-avoidant would be characteristical for a Narcissist.
I should also mention I am in day 6 of his silent treatment since I asked him if he ever saw us anything more. He has told me he is afraid to let me in
He actively ppurposefully and manipulatively uses his so-called "shyness" (which can't be all to bad either, if you think about him not having any problems initiating relationships). Using me as an example here again. I cannot tell people about my shyness. I can't. There's nothing I dread more. On the outside, I don't appear to be shy either. It's rather a lack of warmth I think. It'll take me months to years to gradually build up trust in a relationship, and then I will gradually show more and more affection as I feel more safe. Your guy, in contrast, periodically overloads you with affection, only to suddenly shut you off completely again. He isn't shy. But he knows exactly what to tell you. What you want to hear. He wants your heart to melt about "oh, this poor sensitive guy, he's so shy, he needs me", but that's BS. He's manipulating you.
I've googled and researched everything I am dealing with, and it all points to narcissism and avpd.
Yes, I'd also say he's a Narcissist from what you describe. Did you read into closet narcissists/what Millon describes to be "Compensatory Narcissists"?
I feel like I was a normal and confident person before we met, and now I feel lost and alone and crazy. I'm a good person with a good heart, always wanting to help others and I think for that reason alone, I struggle even more so with the ST and being shut out.
There's this saying, the way a person talks about themself tells you more about them than how other people talk about them. I think there's a lot of truth in this. It always makes me suspicious if people refer to themselves to be "helplful" or "so social" and stuff. In my opinion, one doesn't have to be always-helpful. People who have this attitude of self sacrifice often do more harm to themselves and to others than they do good. One doesn't have to be helpful in general, one should be helpful on special occasions, when someone really means a lot to you or when you feel you can empathize with a certain person especially much. You get my point?
Also, have you looked into transference and countertransference? Relationships are always a matter of two persons, never of one alone. There must be a reason you were attracted to this guy, and why you didn't turn away from him as soon as you found out he is as abusive as he is. There must be something about you, the way you think about yourself, which made you stay in this relationship. And I doubt this just "appeared" through this relationship.
To me, you seem to be emotionally dependent to this guy, like a child hoping to be praised by their parents. That's not healthy for you, and it's not responsible towards yourself either. I really hope you get away from him! Being involved with all kinds of "psychology forums" for quiet some time now, I figured out there seems to be no worse than being involved in a narc relationship. There are whole forums for people who are in relationships with narcissists. Maybe you should drop by there.