Brandic, i get what you're saying and im not trying to confuse you either way. cause i seem to be recovering from a dissociative disorder, but i also had a facticious disorder in my teens and had a lot of doctors "wrapped around my little finger", so i know tho denial is a big problem with mental illness, it isn't all always denial. i remember when i first said i really wasn't psychotic in my teens, people started going on about denial which was just so emotionally invalidating. so i am not going to judge you either way. i think you need to figure things out for yourself.
ive spent a lot of time here, but ive spent time working on issues, not just trying to work out what issues i have. i posted what was problematic for me where would help, without worrying too much about dx. some things about dx were things i had to face eventually, but only when they came up cause of my issues.
i wasn't sure i had DDNOS until i integrated and realised how different my experience really was. It could be talked about and treated in the same way as DID, and yes it was related, but I still think there is a difference between my own problems and full DID, even though that difference is probably only a sliding scale from milder to more severe.
about talking to your therapist in funny voices, i guess if it is DID causing it, it will happen whether you like it or not! if not, i can understand getting carried away with things too. when i was one of my child parts i wouldn't talk in a funny voice, i'd i would just be acting/feeling more like a child, lol. my therapist noticed and pointed out how the expression on my face was like the one a child gets, and i looked at what was going on more closely. if i had started talking in funny voices i would have been making that up, though i did often sound & come across different, but it was a lot more subtle than that. - but i felt like i was expected to do things like that if i really did have DID.
brandic wrote:Just because I have a really good imagination and can act really well doesn't mean I have some serious mental disorder. But the sad part about the whole thing is, I don't even think I'm acting. I've convinced myself that this is what it is. Between me and my therapist, well... we're quite a pair of crazies aren't we.
this is where it gets confusing for you, and i really relate to that from more than one perspective.
brandic wrote:Maybe I was miserable before my DID diagnosis, but at least I wasn't delusional! Now all of a sudden it seems that alters are coming out of the f#@king woodwork. You just open the gate one little crack and they come pouring through. Are you kidding? With names and everything? I feel like a f@#king sideshow!
well, my delusions (lol) didn't have names, i had to ask them to choose. it didn't all come pouring through just like that, they appeared more slowly one by one and i didn't really know what was going on. the delusional thing is tricky both ways, i guess there are different sorts of delusions - the sort that you get in psychosis like schizophrenia, and what i guess you could call "soft delusions". i think both convincing yourself you have a mental illness, and having DID involve delusions you could call "soft delusions", but at the same time obviously that does not mean one is the same as the other, only that both are caused by pain of some sort, and trying to escape that somehow, which i think it what im calling "soft delusions" are really about. im sure there's some proper term for it all, but im just trying to explain things, this isn't psychological advice, more just a nutty person trying to relate experiences

brandic wrote:I have more control over my own life than to let my imagination run wild with crap like this. It's getting ridiculous. Really, really ridiculous. I just need to stop playing these stupid games that I've been playing. Because they aren't funny anymore. And my therapist really needs to slow down this freakin DID wheel from spinning out of absolute freakin control before someone or something gets hurt. Shouldn't she be the one doubting it, not me? What is wrong with this picture???
If they are games, no they're not funny cause they are hurting you.

If it is DID, it is confusing like that. I found the same thing with therapists. mine was the one to suggest DID first when i explained what was going on, but when i (experienced right then as E.) needed to play games with her and manipulate her into believing i didn't have DID to distance myself from more vulnerable feelings that were other parts of me, she fell straight for it (even though I had warned her about E.) i think the idea was that therapists are supposed to validate, but at the same time, there is more to it that just simple validation.
brandic wrote:Okay so I've had a hard time falling asleep tonight. I've had yelling voices in my head. So what, I'm gonna magically turn those voices into alters and call them persecutors??? GET A LIFE CAROLINE! I'm having a hard time falling asleep because I'm too lazy to get my ass off the couch and into my bed! It's as simple as that! Why does it have to be some long, complicated explanation for everything. It's really not that complicated!
I guess the answer is to figure out what ARE the voices? if they're saying persecutory things, what in your own feelings about yourself might that be related to. people can have voices with or without DID, but DID or not maybe isn't so important there, the feelings are still probably there somewhere, however they are coming out.
brandic wrote:I hope I didn't trigger anyone by my rant, but then again I'm sick and tired of being worried about each and every word I say, and whether it's going to hurt someone's feelings on here.
Get off those damn eggshells!

you're posting what you genuinely feel. keep doing it.
brandic wrote:I DON'T THINK I CAN TAKE IT FOR ONE MORE SECOND! I refuse to be put in a box and labeled. Isn't my existence more meaningful than a bunch of labels??? I need to break out of this freakin box! STOP LABELING ME!
I relate. LOL but i also understand now that doesn't mean people just see me as a label either.
brandic wrote:I spend so much of my work time, when I should be doing other things, on this stupid site. Ugh. It sickens me and yet I don't know what I can do about it.
well... this post looks helpful. there's one good reason to spend time working on your problems - so you don't have problems any more. the risk is getting stuck in a pattern where you are posting places like here, and not working on your problems but possibly exacerbating them or playing them out by distracting yourself from the real problem. trying to work out "what you have" can be one way of doing that!
good on you for having the guts to post your feelings about this honestly, don't be embarassed about your rant or edit it out, if that's what you feel, you're doing exactly what you should be doing here.

brandic wrote:Johnny-Jack wrote:'ve been depressed in my life, debilitating depressions, and therapy's never fixed it. My three older "alters" all admit we're the same person, that this whole thing was a big mistake, we made it all up. The babies, they're a part of me too.
Yes, I think some of my parts are convinced that we don't have DID (and have tried talking me out of it - talk about irony) and others think we do but we are all "me".
Lol! I had that too. E convinced my therapist that
we don't have DID...

i mean its even stupid as a sentence!
brandic wrote:You make a good point here. I've asked myself the same question. Am I really that good of an actor? I don't think so. And also, why would I possibly want to make this up...?
I was, and i pretended to be bipolar. my alters felt different about that. one wanted to manipulate the professionals cause they were "authority figures" and had to be controlled. another one was very sad and lonely/dejected. another wanted something so desperately, a need to be loved, but we couldn't process that properly, so it all went horribly wrong. i know it was all me now. but the ways i acted were often ways i wouldn't have acted if i had been one person. i couldn't see all those different perspectives at once, i couldn't weigh things up and make the right desicions. all i could see was what i saw and felt through the eyes of who i was at the time.
brandic wrote:Johnny-Jack wrote: The discussion on DID vs DDNOS is freaking me out too. Academically it's fascinating but I can't participate. Did I have DID as a kid, that turned into DDNOS (losing maybe 0.01% of time for decades, regular people lose more than that), now it's back to DID because I chose to deal with this? The T says it doesn't matter and doesn't even like the distinction.
Yes, I do really need to stop worrying about this. My T says the same thing, and somehow my mind becomes obsessed with trying to figure out which one it is! The truth is, there is no doubt I'm dissociative, and there is no doubt I have different pronounced personality states who think and act very differently. Whether it's DID or DDNOS is like a dog trying to chase its own tail.
Agree. work on what is going on for you, - meaning what you think and feel - not trying to label it. that kinda immunises you from convincing yourself you have disorders you don't have too!
brandic wrote:Johnny-Jack wrote: I was journaling before joining this board and coming up with insights and flashbacks daily and now still flashbacks but most memories are blocked by some fictional "thing" I call a sphinx.
Is the sphinx now fictional? Or has it/he always been?
about fictional... Some of my memories were blocked by alters, some i couldn't access unless the right part of me was there at the time. there are memories i still don't access. but when it comes down to it - as a whole person, those memories are blocked by me. I'm having enough of a hard time dealing with what i have to deal with. i couldn't cope with them right now. i don't want to. if i think about it, i think about it like i am watching from 100 yards away. right now i dont want to remember - why the ###$ should i? i don't need alters to know that any more. i knew as much as i needed to to get to where i am now. the rest would be too much for me to cope with until i have done a lot more healing.
whether your sphinx is "some fictional thing" its "there" because you are not ready for those memories right now.
brandic wrote:Johnny-Jack wrote:Why did I even open this Pandora's box in therapy? Everyone who's supposedly inside had slept mostly for decades. I want to go back to the crappy dead life before all this showed up.
YES! Pandora's Box. That's exactly how it feels sometimes.
again, i relate to how that feels, it feels like you've opened up something and thought WTF have i got myself into?

but that is what is there. the way i see it, those parts of you waking up is the bit in the middle of being half dead/half alive and fully living. its scary, overwhelming and confusing.
LinaeveWorkman wrote:The reason I posted my questions here, is because it's easier for others to look in than for you to look in. At least, it is for me. Sometimes other people see things where I will try to rationalize it all away. -hug- Sounded like you needed that here.
Yes, you've got a good point here. It's really easy to rationalize things away on our own, and it's really invaluable having the feedback and "outsiders perspective" of others.[/quote]
agree.
LinaeveWorkman wrote:Perhaps, and not to anger you or frustrate you further, but perhaps you have stuffed them down for so long that they are leaking out slowly? Maybe most stayed hidden for a while?
brandic wrote:I need to be more gentle and loving with myself about it.
Yes, you do!

brandic wrote:LinaeveWorkman wrote:I won't tell you it's normal. I can't. What the heck is normal? If I have DIDs, then mine is definitely not the same as your description, nor is it the same as Una+'s. Nor do you two sound the same. So what would be 'normal'? According to the DMV? Even that's not a good indication, considering the amount of DDNOS out there.
Yes, I'm noticing that DID manifests itself differently in everyone as well, that there is no "normal" with DID lol.
I think cause its created by our mind to protect us, it IS a product of our own minds, and will be as different and individual as each person who has it.
brandic wrote:LinaeveWorkman wrote:Your not being labeled. If anything, you are being labeled as Brandic to me. Brandic is kind, patient, and a little eccentric. Brandic is knowledgeable. Brandic is a little upset and frustrated right now. But Brandic is not this tiny little box called DID, neatly labeled and shelved somewhere.

You exist. I don't know (yet) your hobbies, or your job, or anything like that, but I would like to know (not trying to sound creepy) because Brandic is a very interesting person.
Thank you, this brought a smile to my face.
That's a lovely way of putting it Linaeve. and you're right everyone is so much more than just their disorder.

brandic wrote:LinaeveWorkman wrote:About believing, or not....You can always stuff them in a box. Stuff them away, ignore the voices, and eventually they may subside again. But, who knows what will happen then? Maybe 'Sam' was an alter of mine, and after years of literally keeping her locked up, she finally caused my meltdown. I never want another meltdown, ever. If I have to dredge 'Sam' up and look her straight in the face and take her beating for the years she's been locked away, so be it. As long as I am sane enough to keep working, keep breathing, keep being a mom... I've never had an inner world either (other than my daydreams). No house, no garden (my friend has an inner garden she takes care of), no nothing.
Beautifully said. I'm a master stuffer. This rant was one big angry (albeit needed) stuff. But if I want to heal and get better, I must acknowledge the reality that I have parts of me who have been very hurt, and really need love and kindness right now. So... thanks.
Lol, yeah, i relate to those things too. and i never had an inner world either. some of my alters had rooms or places they were in, (and interesting cause i did dream about those places a lot when asleep.) but that was it really.