If someone hurts/kills someone, or commits any crime, out of their own control, there is no justifying imprisonment, in my opinion. I think it's sick and disgusting that there are people who would hold someone responsible for something they did not choose and had no power to stop.
"They're a danger to society" is not a good enough argument. First of all, which society? Second of all, nobody is born obligated to participate or behave in society in any way. That's something that is usually forced upon a person and it's a shame - a crying damn shame - that there are penalties for choosing your own way of life. Third of all, any society so callous and ignorant of individual rights is no society that I value.
I am for putting the person in a hospital (which I suppose could count as imprisonment, but this is for an entirely different purpose), where they will be treated, nurtured, entertained, given proper medical and emotional attention. Able to see and speak to their loved ones, flexibly. Clothed, cleansed and spoken to in a dignified manner. Given as much privacy as is safe to permit them. Educated. Allowed to exercise and step foot outside on at least a daily basis (with supervision). Then released when they are ready to resume their life without having to worry about not being in control of themselves. This would all be for the person's own good and "society" will benefit from it, too.
But jail is never a justifiable option in my opinion. I would much rather see the "criminal" walk free than punished for something they were:
A- Not responsible for. (Unless they knew they were ill and, when in control, actively decided to neglect themselves. I know that I have alters and refuse to seek professional help. If one of my alters killed someone, that is my fault. I am not doing all I can to claim control over my illness and I know that. Relinquishing control is not the same as losing it, or having never had it.)
B- A victim themselves.
People are so busy calling violent people and murders "dangerous" and "monstrous" to realize that they are becoming that way themselves. And it literally makes me sick. I feel more secure around known killers than I do around some of the people who judge them.
Stop being lazy, "society". Actually give as many f--ks about human life as you say you do. Actually think things through and look at the whole picture before formulating an opinion. Actually use that empathy you were born with, and the common sense you claim to have. Actually observe and study the person. Do your JOB. Less jails, more hospitals.
And NEVER jail for the mentally ill. Give them the same chance at a normal, healthy life that the rest of us take for granted as we throw labels around to feel even more disgustingly self-righteous.
I'm seriously thinking of leaving this site. Nothing wrong with the site, but some of the people here just make me want to hurl. Them.