walden wrote:I think you're right..people don't usually have a back and forth between different voices in their head do they?
I don't think so, but I'm probably not the best person to ask

My friend says his head is completely quiet

The only time my head was ever quiet was when my alters left for a day... believe me, talking to yourself is completely different, when it's actually just talking to yourself (and no one is even there to listen). And I didn't like the silence, either.
walden wrote:Canolime, thats interesting you mentioned that...I have had lots of thoughts where I didn't think it was me, that I just took in stride. Do you have an example of what that is like for you? Thanks!
Well, there are different degrees. I mean, before I knew anything about DID, some comments I had no problem thinking they were my own, others I questioned, and some scared me half to death because there's no way they could have been mine.
For instance, if I heard something like "Let's go over there" or "Awww, look how cute they are" (talking about puppies or something), I had no problem believing that could have been me, even if it was more like I heard it inside my head, instead of thought it. If I heard "No, don't do that", and I'd start arguing with "myself" about it, I would think it's a little odd that I'm pretty much ordering myself not to do something, when I
really want to do it and don't think it's a bad idea (I'd even feel like someone was mad at me, if I did something they didn't like). Sometimes I would hear things like "I hate him" (my dog), and I was so horrified and puzzled about why I would think that, when I knew I didn't hate him. And then there were times I'd hear things that were obviously not my own thoughts... like someone would tell me some kind of information, and then I would find out what they told me was true, but I knew
I didn't know that information, so it obviously wasn't my own thoughts... that's when I would get scared

Now, I usually recognize even the comments that I wouldn't have really questioned. I think the only times I might not be sure who said what, is when I'm distracted.
I think if you only heard a comment, and were surprised (like "Huh? What did you say?"), there's a good chance it wasn't you who said it

walden wrote:The other day, I was walking down a corridor to my office at work when a man I work greeted me when we passed. A tough male voice in my head said "The name is Rach" (pronounced like Rachel, but without the "el"). It really startled me. I tried to convince myself its just my mind playing tricks, but I don't think thats truly the case.
Sometimes, it's kind of hard to deny them really existing, huh? You should have asked about it (asked whoever said "The name is Rach"). That's probably the best way to know if someone actually said something.