gwilly wrote:[quote="If it is a problem, it's a problem. If it isn't a problem, it isn't. I don't think morality for the sake of morality should enter into it, EVER. It should never be about "well this is wrong because people have said it is for hundreds of years.... even though we really don't know why."
The only person who can know what's wrong with it is you. If it effects your health, for example, then yes it's a problem. If it doesn't negatively effect you, then there's no reason to be against it save for being puritan for puritan's sake just because somebody told you that's how it's supposed to be. It's practically like a doctor telling you that you are sick when you aren't.
And things don't effect everyone the same way. Also we have to watch out when giving labels to things, is it your label, or someone else's? What one person calls addiction, another person may not see as a problem. Who's view do we go by in discussion?
gwilly wrote:
I don't think morality for the sake of morality should enter into it, EVER. It should never be about "well this is wrong because people have said it is for hundreds of years.... even though we really don't know why."
.........................................................................................................................................................
If the Morality for Morality sake should not EVER enter into the PORNOGRAPHY Question of what it right and wrong, then who's responsibility is it to see that "every existing form" of sexual pornography is what ("some") people believe as a behavioral norm is governed with moral justice?
Some people define their own standard decrees and laws of morality far distanced from mainstream morality that most often has a strong basis in religious morality.
Too often Pornography spoon-feeds the lower primitive nature of mankind.
The truth is simple but sometimes hard to express. Sex can be beautiful. Sexual attraction may lead a person to seek out a mate, and help to bond a lasting relationship in which children can be born and raised. That is what it was designed to do. But uncontrolled sexual impulses destroy lives and damage society. Essentially every honest adult will have to admit that they have had sexual thoughts that they KNOW should never be acted out.
If I look at sexually stimulating pictures or words, they can produce a powerful emotional reaction that draws my interest and makes it hard to stop looking. My focus is on the image as an object, even though it may be a picture of a person who in real life has feelings, hopes and dreams. Further, it makes me think -- very selfishly -- only of how this makes ME feel.
How I react to this sort of situation depends on my worldview. If I believe that every thought is basically good or that the most important thing in life is my own pleasure, I will pursue my desires wherever they go. If I recognize the evil bent of my human nature, I will be on my guard and avoid being led down any dangerous path, which is what pornography does.
If I am honest, I know what sort of material affects me in this way. If I am not insightful or have other reasons for being blind to the issue -- such as being addicted to pornography or because in some way I profit from it -- then I may demand a definition. Pornography can be defined, although the criteria tend to be vague, and borderline cases exist where individuals may truly differ in their interpretation. But the real problems lie in the material that is nowhere near the border and is far over "the fine line."
For those who produce or distribute pornography and refuse to regulate themselves, there needs to be external controls. This is possible because pornography can be defined and legal action can be taken although it must be done for each piece of material as a separate case. This means that many people need to be involved as watchdogs and whistleblowers. Yet it is vitally important to do this because pornography destroys lives.
How is pornography destructive? Sexual images are extremely persistent. Men who started with pornography as young boys often can remember in great detail the images that got them started and continue to be affected by them. But the major danger is that the intensity of the material tends to escalate because after a while the mild stuff is no longer as stimulating. The images become associated with masturbation and it is the nature of orgiastic activity that it produces a desire for repetition.
When sex is kept within the context of marriage, this habit-forming tendency helps cement the commitment and motivate a couple to work out the inevitable problems that go with human relationships. But sexual stimulation with pornography, because it is devoid of human interaction, is intensely selfish and becomes quickly jaded. Thus the fantasies need to become more explicit, more bizarre and more blended with violence to achieve the same level of excitement. Finally, images alone are not enough and the desire to act out the fantasies becomes powerful. Since the focus has been consistently on selfish pleasure and the pictures seen as objects, the transition is sometimes frighteningly easy.
So pornography makes monsters of susceptible people, mostly men who started as boys. Rapists, child molesters and serial killers uniformly are addicted to pornography. To say that some who use pornography do not reach this extreme is beside the point. For some, it "only" makes sexual fulfillment in marriage difficult if not impossible. This is because the patterns are so hard to change and the pornography user finds the mate inferior to his fantasies. There is a parallel here with alcohol. Some people do not have a problem with it, but their use may inadvertently lead others to use, abuse and ultimately be destroyed. With pornography, the danger is so dramatic, why play around with it?
But we also need to think about the subjects of pornography. They are not simply those people who have made a career choice to enter the sex industry. The sad truth is that it is usually vulnerable young adolescents who have been tricked, seduced, coerced or bullied into a lifestyle of degradation that often ends in death, from suicide, drug overdose or murder. Pimps, often themselves shaped for their heartless role by pornography, prowl the malls of this nation, looking for suitable youngsters.
Young girls, or boys for the homosexual community, are approached and dealt with according to their vulnerabilities. Those who are rebellious are lured into what sounds like excitement. Those who crave attention or approval are told they would be great models. They might be photographed decently but have their faces attached to computer-altered pornographic websites. Some believe that the pimp is their boyfriend and have their minds slowly twisted to the point that they become exotic dancers, pornography subjects or prostitutes.
Pornography is not a victimless crime. The users and the subjects are both devastated and the societal cost is immense. It is only the subject of debate because of human nature. Sexual behavior is very highly rationalized -- people are capable of justifying anything they really want to do. The profit motive is powerful for those who make this a business and, in the case of pornography, organized crime controls the major portion of it. Smokescreens, such as preservation of free speech, are off the point for that principle does not mean we can say anything we wish. Yelling "fire" in a crowded theater or maliciously slandering another person are not protected. And we are not just talking about Venus de Milo. Even though there are individual differences in response to nude representations, pornography is light years removed from real art.
Just as it is not sensible to try crack cocaine "just to see what it is like," the wisest answer to pornography is to "just say never." But to those who justify the porn industry, I along with so many who have a conscious sense of morality to state; "We will not remain silent and will not tolerate the destruction of lives of women, children, and men in the name of freedom."
Peace
Chris