Hi Cabalistic,
I'm really glad that you replied to my post. Thank you. You didn't make me feel bad at all. Actually, I feel a little bit more relieved.
You hit the nail on the head with "groomed." He was hugely in favor of homeschooling me. Of course, that can be attributed to how much interest he took in my education (history, literature, etc.) But there is still a scary component to that thought.
To be honest, he didn't overstep his boundaries
much.
1- He said that my mother was always concerned about the relationship between him and me. This was before any abuse happened to me (that I know of).
2- He said (several times over the past months) that he wanted to read me a poem that he wrote for my mother. (He writes a lot.) I told him that the "passionate" details of his relationship with my mother are sacred to them and should be kept that way. Well, he read me the poem anyway.
3- I told him what my ex-stepfather and the "friend of the family" did. "Dan" asked me about the specific details.
4- "Dan" told me that we weren't "really" related, not by blood anyway.
5- "Dan" told me that, if I were not his daughter, he could easily fall in love with me. I told him that sometimes bonds are stronger between adoptive parents. Or something loosely translated as such. I don't remember what he said.
Combined with his comment about "the spark between us", this is enough red flags for me. I'm gone. I just haven't told him yet.
You're right--it's probably not a good idea to lie about my reason for leaving. I think that you're also right that I'm not responsible for him. He has lived without me for the past 16 years, and he will manage without me from now on.
I've been working through this in several posts now, and I think I'm actually going to call him in a few days. I think I'll tell him something like this:
(Not gonna call him anything, not "Dan", not "papa". I'll just say hello.)
There are some things I need to say, and I need you to listen to me.
About the other night: I understand how hard you worked to contain yourself with me when I was a kid. And I think that you were always a great father. However, the abuse by my other stepfather created some really bad memories for me. I don't think that you want to hurt me or to do anything bad to me, but I can't be around you. Please understand that this is important for my mental health. I can't afford to get you two confused. I need to remember you as my father, who only saw me as a daughter. I am glad to see that you are still interested in chess. I hope that you will see your friend soon. I hope that you take good care of yourself, because you are a good person. I won't be contacting you again.
I think that this shows that I'm sensitive to his condition. That I respect that he contained himself. That I care about his well-being. And also that I am GONE.
I might revise this slightly. I'll have to run it by my fiance.
Thank you again for replying to me.

--Frayed
{Edit:} Ran this by my fiance; he suggested that I hang up after that and turn off my phone.
I might also want to tell "Dan" that neither my mother nor my grandmother put me up to this. I might want to add that I am not planning telling any of them about this. The only thing that would do is upset them, anyway.
I will tell my stepbrother that "Papa" and I had a falling out. But I can still see my stepbrother, his fiance and myself catching up over lunch while he is in town. My stepbrother is currently working abroad, but will be visiting in July and then settling down out of state. He hasn't lived with "Dan" since he was a little kid. I'm going to e-mail him right now, actually.
Anyway, thanks again!
Do not take my advice before talking to your doctor/counselor/other professional. Depending on where you live, you may be able to find free, confidential care. Most importantly, sometimes your shrink can be wrong. Get a second opinion.