Janie wrote:Caring, really caring, leads to all kinds of battles and wars. Being indifferent, not caring about anything, leads to, well, nothing. No one gets passionate about nothing. You have to care, really care, before you're willing to do something.
i'm sorry, but i totally disagree.
some wars are fought due to people caring; the spanish civil war, world war two etc.
but most, throughout history, are fought by the total lack of caring shown by those in power for anything other than greed.
early intra-european war was over land and control of territory and peoples.
the crusades were fought over territory, and control of trade routes (ie money). people think they were fought because of care for religious integrity but that's crap.
the napoleonic wars: territory and control of empires.
colonial conflict (including the "genocide" of native americans by white settlers): territory and control of "the other" (ie people who weren't white)
world war one: possibly the grossest act of uncaring disgrace ever. fought over the territorial control of a city, and fear of loss of face, by 6 empire states, none of whom had the slightest regard for the people who did the actual fighting.
the first gulf war could potentially be seen as "caring" about the plight of kuwaitis but you can bet that the americans welcomed the opportunity to embed their military powers in an oil rich region.
the iraq war: fought on a tissue of lies: north korea, at around the time of the WMD fiasco, was waving its arms and yelling that it had nuclear weaponry. everyone ignored them. so clearly no one cared about WMD.
bin laden went from world's most wanted to someone the US govt admitted they didn't care about in the space of a few months. everyone ignored the fact that bin laden and hussein hated eachother.
even going into the war, no one cared enough, in the war office, to think of a viable exit strategy: no one cared what would happen to the iraqi state and people after invasion. they just cared about the territory and the resources.
i think that wars fought over people genuinely caring about something enough to stand up for their beliefs are sadly incredibly rare.
*...hell is other people - Jean Paul Sartre...* *...i owe my solitude to other people - alan watts...*