Look, personally speaking, I think what you did was wrong (indeed, it is similar to what I myself did). Not evil. Not worthy of death. But wrong. Maybe you'd even feel better in the long-run if you were sentenced and punished. But the most important thing is how your friend feels about what you did and what she wants from you. She feels okay. She does not believe she was abused. She wants you to move on.
I've just (rather self-destructively) spent the last two days reading about the Stanford rape case and
you clearly aren't in the same category as that guy. What you did was bad, but it was not monstrous. Personally I think it might make sense to say you acted in an abusive way, but you are not a rapist - and I suspect law enforcement and most people would agree.
Furthermore, you were still a kid and I don't believe adults should be forever burdened by their behaviour as a child. Try to draw a line in the sand at '18' separating 'adult you' and 'child you'. On a real, physical level you are a different person. The brain keeps grows and developing until one's mid-20s. If your brain is different then 'you' are also different.
The best thing you can do right now is to listen to your friend and respect her wishes not to take the matter so seriously and accept that she is fine. If you want to feel like you are redeeming yourself/ earning a place in society, then educating others about good consent, calling out rape jokes, and maybe volunteering at a shelter would be a great start.
The fact of the matter is, there is still a scary amount of cognitive dissonance and hypocrisy when it comes to the topic of sexual offending. People like to believe that abusers are monsters comprising 0.1% of the population and that all that we need to do to change society is to identify and kill such people. But then look at studies like this:
http://vaw.sagepub.com/content/early/2016/05/30/1077801216651339.full.pdfWe found that 54.3 percent of the intercollegiate and recreational athletes and 37.9 percent of non-athletes had engaged in sexually coercive behaviors – almost all of which met the legal definition of rape.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12806533We investigated women's and men's reports of experiencing and using tactics of post-refusal sexual persistence, defined as persistent attempts to have sexual contact with someone who has already refused [...] More men (40%) than women (26%) reported having used such tactics; this difference was significant for the sexual arousal, emotional manipulation and lies, and intoxication categories.
Does that mean that pressuring someone into sexual activity is okay? No. Absolutely not. It is always wrong. Consent might be engaged, mutual, continuous and enthusiastic (with both partners over the age of consent, unless they are very close in age).
Are the majority of people sexual offenders? No ~ meaning it is not normal behaviour.
But as you can see **it is horribly common** ... which is to say, sexual offenders aren't the one-in-a-million demons society likes to believe.
And the reasons so many people in society want to believe this. 1.) It is comforting to think that your likelihood of being abused is super low and that if you just identify and then stay away from the tiny 0.1% you will be okay. 2.) It means you don't have to examine your own past behaviour from when you were young and consider whether your partner was actually kind of nervous when you first had sex; or whether you grabbing your friend's boobs as a joke was actually sexual assault; or whether you didn't guilt trip your partner into doing stuff by complaining when they weren't in the mood etc. (all hypothetical but common enough examples).
'Cause a lot of the men online who call for rapists to be raped in prison or say how they'd go out and personally kill all sex offenders if they could get away with it may well have done one of the above. Quite probably as a kid/ teenager. Because kids and teenagers are often selfish and because most of us in the West receive zero sex education and learn through watching porn and teen comedies.
What does all this mean?
Well, it isn't an excuse. It doesn't let you off the hook per se. But it does mean you are **not** the monstrous outsider that you fear yourself to be.
It also means it is your moral and social responsible to stay alive and contribute to society now that you "get it". As it is my responsibility too.
Because there are a lot of calculated, repeat predators out there who will never feel any remorse. There are also far, far more guys who lack the self-awareness to consider themselves abusers, having committed abuse. The amount of decent, enlightened people who have never abused and never will is not big enough. The world needs self-reflective people.
Cause there is a massive sea change going on. Our parents' generation and the generation before them simply didn't have this big discussion around consent that is happening right now. Here in Britain it was still legal for a man to rape his wife
until 1991! People in their 40s and 50s and 60s talk as though this is a sudden generation of debauched, amoral predators. No. American has had a slave rapist (Thomas Jefferson) and a date rapist (Grover Cleveland) as president. Think about the amount of rock n' roll icons from the 70s (David Bowie; Iggy Pop; Jimmy Page; Bill Wyman etc. etc.) who abused children.
What you did was very small compared to that stuff. You didn't rape anyone. You coerced a peer as a child. It was crappy, but it is forgivable. You
have been forgiven by the girl in question.
So you can and must go on. I believe you can do it. Re-read what others on here have said. Note we are all moderators - we wouldn't lie to you or not take what you are saying seriously. Take deep breaths and know that your life is not over. You are a human being who can change and accomplish wonderful things. You have the victim's permission to do so. She says she is not harmed. Listen to that.
You might find this article useful. Please try to take it on board:
http://everydayfeminism.com/2016/02/be-accountable-when-abusive/P.S. I repeat - you are not a rapist. You aren't going to find many people who take this stuff as seriously as I do (due to my own remorse). This is kind of me at my hardest and most serious tbh because you said you felt that the others were being too easy on you.
Please discuss this with a therapist and accept the fact that you may well have OCD. I very much doubt you will be reported, although I know more about British law in this area than American. I hope some of this reply helps.