It's good to hear you are seeing a professional.
toefreckle90 wrote:He always listens but feels awful because he doesn't know how to comfort me/relate.
Your therapist or the boy you are in love with?
Non-professionals often don't know how to relate and comfort others that express a history of past abusive experiences. I know personally I've endured a lot of silence when I've told people about my experiences in the past. People just don't know what to do or say a lot of the time. I think sometimes it can help if you direct how you'd like them to react like "I just need you to listen" etc. There might also be some resources on the net maybe in the "supporting someone who's been through rape and abuse" vain? Maybe you could take a look (google?) and see if there was anything that had good suggestions about how people can support you and print some off for him?
toefreckle90 wrote: I was never timid before that relationship, but after all the awfulness I am now, and I'm afraid of opening up.
That is very understandable to not want to open up after having gone through the experiences you have been through. As you gradually work at communicating and feeling safe with people again I'm sure that you will be able to seek the support and openness you need in a relationship again, it may just take some time and work.
How are you feeling about the therapist you are seeing?