by avatar123 » Sun Feb 04, 2018 3:25 am
It may be that she both loves him as a brother and wants to have a normal sibling relationship with him, but also hates him for what he did to her. The dichotomy of a love/hate relationship is not uncommon when sexual abuse occurs within families. It's part of the damage that's been done.
Some people try to sweep it under the rug and normalize things, so as not to deal with the hate and other negative emotions. Others can't get past the hurt and hate and mistrust, and cut off all contact. Some people are in the middle and may vacillate back and forth or have a partial relationship, depending on circumstances.
There is no "correct" response, any of the above may be valid and appropriate for that person. It also depends on how and when the abuse occurred. was it violent or loving, was it forced or voluntary, was it between kids or was an adult involved, was it repetitive or a one-time thing. Lots of variables and complexity.
For society in general, looking in from the outside, it may seem like the relationship logically should be ended. But it often isn't that simple, and emotions play a very large part. The ties that bind, as they say, truly are strong. Familial bonds are among the strongest.
My advice would be to listen and be supportive. If you suspect that he is manipulaing her or is being dishonest or presents a threat, you can tell her that and explain why, but realize it's her choice and decision, as to what the relationship will be.