by xdude » Mon Jul 08, 2013 12:11 pm
catch22 -
Yes, it's a complicated topic, but behind the topic is a seemingly simple philosophical question. What works better? Every cell/insect/animal/human for itself? Or.. Cooperative behavior?
In reality it's not that simple, not a black or white matter, but it is a key question that has deep implications. In the short term (relative to how long life has been on earth), humans are rapidly proliferating, apparently because of their cooperative efforts, but long term? Long term there is the possibility we cause our own species to fail, whether that's due to resource exhaustion, war*, or due to some small organism like a virus defeating us.
*The book does talk about the apparent reality though that group cooperation is also related to why we humans fight so much with each other. That because of our strong tendency to association ourselves with a group, we also are inclined to fight with others who are in a different group, even if we share 99% of the same genes. Racism, sexism, nationalism, tribalism, my family vs your family, my team vs your team, etc., are all examples of group vs group thinking that often ends up with us fighting with each other.
It goes beyond that though. An earth covered with vast quantities of less cooperative creatures doesn't have an obvious long term value either.
I have no answers, but I do see some parallels between how individuals approach life. Where 'disordered' types may tend to be mostly focused on what they want/need, while neurotic types may tend to focus more on what the group want/needs. Neither is entirely content all the time. Still in the context of this thread, it does seem many disordered types want (or think they want) the benefits of neurotic/cooperative relationships, but at the same time want the benefits of their 'disordered'/separatist thinking too.
It's been written many times, that for all an HPD's social behavior and approval seeking, she/he is essentially a loner, and on some level, apparently, doesn't want to be too tied down to any one relationship, wants the benefits of being a loner too.
We do NOT delete posts
Read the forum rules before posting here. If you are having any doubts about what you are posting, if you are thinking in the back of your mind, "I am going to want to delete this, or these details, later", remove those details, or step back and don't post until you are sure.