Moderators: Snaga, NewSunRising, lilyfairy
Zor wrote:PlanetIcarus wrote:
Are you actually asking your God's opinions from us? How many types of cross-dressing do you know that aren't for inner girls of someone's? Learn to judge yourself as you do others, or just stop being such a hypocrite. -JON-
I wasn't asking that at all… just if others had had similar experiences or feelings and how they were addressed… Please don't be so harsh… I am confused and a little scared by all this still, and was seeking advice from people that may have had similar struggles to figure out how I could approach this one myself. Nothing more, nothing less.
PlanetIcarus wrote:Don't be offended by Jonathan, he means good. He's usually very silent, but when he has something to say, he says big opinions very shortly, and can sound pretty cruel because he doesn't do any explaining, which he actually is not. He defends any minority or any people he thinks are mistreated, including you if someone would offend you for having mental illness.
He also tests peoples reactions. He comes out kind of rude, but having valid point and then he sees how others respond. Do they get angry, if they do, how angry and how are they on their worst, so can they be trusted. Do they hear at all what he has to say, or respond just with feeling. If he's being heard, he can have actual conversations as well, but won't if he's not heard anyway.
There is a very trustworthy person inside that layer of titanium. And he is as harsh for himself than he is for others, he is honest about his true motives. He's not very keen on religious people, who many times are very judgmental, but still don't take any responsibility about their choices but hide behind their Gods.
PlanetIcarus wrote:So.. translating his answer: he doesn't see why there would be any point of talking about is something right or wrong, if you don't make any free choices or take any responsibilities on your own anyway. He is not going to analyze opinions of your God's. He's only willing to discuss with people who are able to make their own choices, because if his opinion is not going to have any meaning to you, why would he give it.
PlanetIcarus wrote:If you call male body wearing female clothing, or vise versa, cross-dressing, when you are talking about others, and say it is a no-no, without caring if they are female/male inside or not, it is called cross-dressing when your body does it too. Your case is not more special than any transgender's. Gender issues are gender issues, and it is the same thing with or without DID.
If you understand there is a true reason for them to dress for who they are also, if you are willing to realize transgender people or transvestites or any people with any kind of gender differences do also have a legit reason to dress to their inner true selves, then you can allow it to your girls also, to be fair. But if you allow yourselves to do stuff you can just no-no from others, that is pure hypocrisy. And that was what you were asking about. That it is a no-no, but aren't you a special case. His answer was NO, you are not special, you are like others.
PlanetIcarus wrote:So to him, having any conversation or not starts from there. If you are to follow your believes about no-nos, there actually isn't anything to discuss about. Or maybe you open your mind and there is a real question on how to deal with the situation, and he is willing to discuss it. So it is purely up to you.
PlanetIcarus wrote:You see, Jonathan is quite a logical thinker, and if he sees a question as not really legitimate, that is a problem which needs to be solved first. I'm not saying he's the easiest person to have a conversation with, he's quite intense with details being right. I think he reacted sounding judgmental, because to him you sounded judgmental. He's not sorry about that, so I won't apologize, I'm more like trying to build a bridge if it is wanted, or maybe you just don't speak to each other, which is fine with him and me also.
myce wrote:Zor the way I would approach this, I think rules need to have reasons. If your god is against cross-dressing, why is that? Maybe you were taught that you're not allowed to question your god. But that doesn't make any sense does it? Why would a god give you a brain to think and then prohibit you from using it? If a god can't answer a question, why obey or respect such a god? Because of fear, because church leaders teach people to fear god and then parents teach their children. Religion is used to control people. In ancient times there was some reason why people were prohibited from cross-dressing, but does it apply now?
Zor wrote:It was more a question of do I indulge them- in that, should I support that?
NyxX wrote:Zor wrote:It was more a question of do I indulge them- in that, should I support that?
Your parts are you and you are your parts only together do you make your whole. So I feel like its less a case of do you support them and more do you support yourself?
If you think of the yin and yang thing within each person is an element of man there is an element of feminity and within each woman an element if masculinity. At some point your feminity split from you and as a result you have been denying her all and that part of yourself for years. Accepting her is important as are her needs and wants and its also important for her to accept yours.
That doesn't necessarily mean cross dressing especially if you have strong feelings on the subject. But communicate with her find out what she needs and want. I think you have said about getting a post it note from one of your alters so maybe try writing her a note or letter. See if she would be happy with more feminine things around her that don't trouble you. And if she isn't see if you can reach a compromise.
Return to Dissociative Identity Disorder Forum
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 21 guests