barry h wrote:...
Revisiting such awful memories could push a person already struggling that little bit too far?
I mean, they were originally repressed to avoid further trauma as a coping mechanism.
Yes, we can call these repressed emotions "emotional baggage," and if you process the emotions, you get rid of that baggage, it disappears.
Yes, I agree there is some danger/risk. The emotions are not harmful to process in a direct way. As you "vomit" out the grief, rage, embarrassment, fear, whatever, it is not pleasant, but it is not actually painful. Again, it is a relief, like vomiting. Unpleasant in some ways, but you actually PREFER it to holding back and keeping the nauseating stuff inside. Purging can ultimately feel kind of ... well, not good, but cathartic, obviously.
The danger/risk comes in from the fact this is a series of partial measures. You unload one piece of baggage, thus putting out one of the beacons of flashing painful light in our memories, it goes dark, and other, slightly less bright flashing lights might suddenly become noticeable, slightly less painful events from around the same time are now visible and call your attention, and are kind of like new hurts. Not really new, but newly discovered. That can cause us to shift our thinking, our interpretation of past events, who we blame for what. Sometimes, shifting blame from another person to ourselves. That could then increase suicidal ideation.
In a perfect world, once you start this process, you would continue till it was ALL out, all purged. Because when you stop half-way, you now have a new, transformed world view that is STILL skewed by the remaining baggage, but to you it will feel like an epiphany, like the blinders finally came off and now you see what was really going on that YOU were really to blame. Or your father. You may then rush off, half-cocked to harm yourself, your relationships, etc.
The fact is, you DID have blinders come off, but not all of them, so the picture you see still is not accurate. Is it more accurate? Maybe in some ways, but not the ways that count the most. Only when they are all off, can you really have a good perspective and judgment.
I made this mistake myself. As I unpacked repressed emotions and traumas, I would then later reframe my world view, my past actions, tell family and friends how I was changed person, what I had realized. Then a week later, have another session, unpack more, and that further changed my view, and I had to backpedal from what I had said before. Happened enough, I burned bridges & lost some trust with people. I do hope to get it back, it was a learning process. It was not so much that my new releases reversed my thinking, but further nuanced my understanding. Like, I was half right. Then a new release, then a new look at things, see the half that was wrong, correct it, but that correction is only half right. A few days later, further release, see the now 1/4 part wrong, correct it, but that correction is only half right. So I keep getting more right, but still imperfect. Till all the stuff is unpacked, and then there is the "best" assessment we can make. We are still human, we can still be wrong, but now we've reached a foundation of understanding that is not going to be dislodged by further internal revelations.
Optimally, I think, there would be, like, a week-long retreat with facilitators to get some one through all this stuff in one go. I think that'd be enough time with good facilitators, based on how long my own stuff took to bring up.
Oh, and just to be clear, I don't think I'm 100% clear. I'm not even sure that is possible. We release as much as we can find, the brightest lights of pain, work our way down to dimmer suppressed pains, but at a certain point there may be stuff down there, too dim/remote for me to see, still subtly skewing me. It would be hubris to suggest I knew for fact I was 100% clear of suppressed baggage. But I do feel vastly improved. And don't fear too much further "settling" of my foundation / view as more comes up, because I expect these are going to be minor tremors, not huge earthshattering quakes (but also know I might have some surprises buried deep, still waiting to be unearthed, who knows?).
But, you know, death is not the worst thing in the world. Risk is not the worst thing. In a perfect world, people would do this stuff under proper supervision. But in a perfect world, all licensed mental health professionals would be good and passionate about their job, and frankly I have known a lot that were burned out, just doing it to get paid, phoning it in, and everything was all about "cya" to avoid potential liability or hassles with insurers. Those people are going to kneejerk to tell you NOT to do anything not in their standard, insurance-approved play-book for fear of non-reimbursement or liability. So for a lot of us, maybe most, it may literally be impossible to get a really good, invested therapist to vet you for whether this kind of emotional release process is good or bad for you. They will just say, "don't do anything outside what I authorize" just for cya, not because it is truly contraindicated by a thorough evaluation of your unique psychological situation and the proposed alternative approach. If you can find that kind of evaluation, by all means, do it and hold onto that therapist like your life depended on it. If you cannot, maybe it is worth biting the bullet, taking the risk. Would you risk shark infested waters to get from a hellish land to a paradise island? Is this any different? Not without risk, but not all risks are to be avoided.
But, yeah, if you try this, please be 100% aware that you likely will be emptying out your emotional baggage piecemeal, and any new views, notions you get in midst of process are still skewed by the unpacked stuff still inside, you have NOT realized some objective truth about anything, or even your "true" subjective truth, till it is all unpacked. Don't make my mistake and lose friends/family. Even though I feel it is worth it to finally feel healthy, I could have had the health without making people distrust me if I had realized I had a lot more to unpack each time I had a major release and thought, temporarily, I had figured it all out, released all my stuff. Give yourself a week after each release to keep probing your psyche for sore teeth before you even think about decided, "Yeah, now I got it figured out."
One hint: So long as you blame anyone for anything, you probably don't yet have it all figured out. We are all dominos, always a prior cause for our bad acts. All bad behaviors are equivalent to lion killing gazelle. Yes, ugly and painful and violent, causes sadness to some, brutal. But natural. Just for humans, we are so ######6 complicated and have so much sickness/illness compared to animals, that our "natural" lion killing gazelle can look like a rape, a child molestation, child abuse, cyberbullying, etc. I guess it would be more correct to say that a rabid animal attacking other animals is "natural," right? Natural but sick/corrupted. Because nature also includes diseases. We don't "blame" the rabid animal, even if we have to isolate it and put it down. Human monsters are no different. We don't have to blame, but we do have to protect ourselves from sick / dangerous elements. And if we don't have to blame, then we also don't have to blame God. That is a common problem people have raised to be religious, think "God is good." So if bad stuff happens, God can't be to blame, so either there is a person to blame or we are too blame, being born bad, being messed up, broken in some way inherent to our soul, just rotten and worse then others, our secret shame. I think religion somewhat messes us up in this way, makes us insist on "blaming" a human being somewhere along the line, not accepting the domino / natural world reality. Because we must absolve God of bad stuff, so must find other person to "blame." But when you realize we cannot feel pleasure without feeling pain, that it is all relative, cannot taste sweet unless we can taste bitter, too, then the fact bad $#%^ happens is not anything anyone needs to be "blamed" for, it is a necessary component to being able to experience the wonder that is life. That does not mean we long for pain or misery, we try to avoid it. But we also do not need to ultimately find a person or entity to "blame" for it in some ultimate, objective sense.