First some history - I'll try to keep it brief. My son, now 14, is our eldest child. Problems began to emerge when he was 2 - notably with toilet training. He was referred to a psychologist at 3 to deal with encopresis (witholding stools) which persisted until he was 6. A diagnosis of Asperger's was suggested as a possibility at this stage although not pursued
We muddled through the next few years - school was always a problem and parent's evenings invariably ended in tears. When he was 9 we moved house and he was much happier in his new school, thanks mainly to a fabulous (male) teacher who taught him for the 2 years he was there. The move to senior school was traumatic. DS was bullied and very unhappy and we asked for a referral again. By the time this came through we had managed to move him to a local grammar school and it was agreed with the psychologist that we would see how things went at the new school.
That was 18 months ago. He is happier but there continue to be problems. He is very busy with organized hobbies (music, scouts etc) but very rarely socialises informally and is very unpopular in his class at school, where he is seen as a 'geek'. He prefers to interact with adults or with much younger children.
He is very small for his age and physically and emotionally immature. I have 2 daughters (12 and 8 ) who he fights with constantly, recently kicking ED at the bus stop - her leg is still healing 3 weeks later. We do not seem to be able to rationalise with him. So, for example, re the incident with his sister we went through what happened, whether it is ever right to hit people etc etc. He seems to follow the logic (he is very bright) but then always at the end comes back to 'but she annoyed me' or whatever. He seems to externalise everything - so, no one likes him because he's clever etc.
He struggles to join in a conversation - not appearing to pick up social cues. He seems detached from others' feelings and oblivious of the impact of his behaviour on others. I think deep down he is unhappy and would like things to be different - tantrums are fairly common and occasionally he is very destructive, smashing up furniture in his room etc. However, I'm coming round to thinking he either cannot change or doesn't want to. I have a referral back to the psychologist but am wondering if I just have to accept that this is his personality. My husband has some similar though much milder traits and my brother in law has marked difficulties in social interaction. I thought things would get easier as he got older and I'm beginning to feel increasingly frustrated and angry with him. I know that we engineer a lot of situations at home to avoid conflict but still feel that his behaviour has a very negative effect on our family life.
So, after all that I would really appreciate people's opinions, especially as to whether you think there is anything to be gained for any of us in pursuing psychological help.
Thanks.