anagram wrote:This is misleading. Unless you happen to somehow be wealthy without working, you simply can't eat-sleep-and-poop and be good when you're an adult. There are responsibilities that you can't completely avoid, and it's not natural, automatic and instinctive to fulfill them. Nobody likes responsibilities for the sake of responsibilities. You need to have something else that compels you to accept them and pursue what it takes to fulfill them. (Or else you're in trouble.)
I'm not talking about going after a better job, a better relationship, a better lifestyle. I'm talking about going after a job, a relationship, a lifestyle, in contrast to simply going on with nothing of that. If you really manage to be content with exactly what you have at one moment, nothing more, nothing less, you just sit there and wait for death. This is not realistic.
I think you're missing the point of the article. Basic life needs, yes, you need to fulfill. The issue this article raises, which I agree with totally, is that after the
basic life needs being met, people strive for more. The whole idea of life plans isn't only to really meet your immediate needs, but to plan for something "better" than what you have currently. I disagree that it's "Not natural, automatic and instinctive to fulfill them". Our basic needs, as well as our expanded wants are very much "natural" to fulfill. The problem is that, after the basic needs are met, we're in a continuous cycle of needing and wanting more.
If you really manage to be content with exactly what you have at one moment, nothing more, nothing less, you just sit there and wait for death. This is not realistic.
I can't tell you how much I disagree with you here. The very reason why I started studying this area of philosophy is to get more intimate with the exact question of what happens when you are totally satisfied. No, in short, is it a "wait for death scenario". By being totally content, you're just totally content. By "waiting for death", you're again striving for something to happen - another goal, just like everything else. You can't be totally content while "waiting for death", it just doesn't work that way.
I could be a bit bias on this article. This particular subject has been about 12 years of extremely heavy research on my part, and was the basis for the religion I picked up as a result of my early studies. This topic is very big for me.