Greebo wrote:I think if you’ve spent your time gutting small furry things or throwing cats at trains we can safely say you’re not an animal lover, or at least not an animal lover in the commonly accepted sense.
Don't knock it until you've tried it.
I think the issue here is the term 'animal lover'. There's a part of my family who came from farmers and I spent some time as a child on the farm from time to time (I think to give my parents a rest). They have what I'd call the healthy view of what animals are and the relationship we should have with them.
Apart from the past 20+ years, we used animals. Not to say we misused them, but they were food and working assistance. Now they're getting Christmas presents and taken for walks in a handbag.
Anyone who thinks this is normal or even acceptable are f*cked in the head to a degree. We breed pedigree animals for our own likes and, in most cases, this makes them weak and problem-ridden. Dogs are toys, birds are kept in confined areas, etc.
This isn't "loving" the animals, it's torturing them. Animals should be kept in line with their instincts, not in line with some misguided maternal instinct of our own.
Yeah, I've thrown my share of cats at trains (and other people's shares, you're welcome) and I've peeled a fair few, but not because I hate animals; just because it was funny at the time.
I own a dog and a cat (although I'm not sure for how much longer, as it pissed on my shoes and I fear it may be having an accident shortly).
They're not really mine; they're there for the rest of the family, but they get treated like the animals they are.
I trained the dog like a dog. I pinned it down, bit it when it did something wrong, slapped it and conditioned it with a reasonable level of fear - just like it would have experienced in a pack. As such, it's probably one of the most 'socially balanced' animals I know. It has no stress behaviour, does what it's told, and behaves like a lower-order pack animal in our house and is fiercely protective.
I think that people who treat animals like humans and often make comments like "animals won't let you down" are doing so because they're incapable of handling the complex interactions that human relationships involve, but they still need them and so animals are a good surrogate.
Animals won't let you down, true, but then, neither will the vacuum cleaner and, when you're dead, little Foofoo will eat your rotting face while you lie in a pool of your own piss on the kitchen floor.
I took my kids out hunting as soon as they were old enough. They've shot rabbits and carried their dripping little bodies back to the house to be scooped out, chopped up and thrown in a curry.
Simply put, they were taught, "Don't aim a rifle at something you're not willing to kill, and don't kill something you're not willing to eat." The result is that they'll think twice before wasting raw meat. They know that throwing out meat because you chose to order a pizza instead of cooking the chicken in the fridge is killing a chicken for no reason. And they know what that feels like.
I didn't do that because I love animals, I did it because I wanted my kids to be mentally well-balanced and understand the true nature of how the world works.