by Existentialist » Sun Feb 12, 2012 12:31 am
Who says you need them? Nobody. The decision is between a doctor and patient. Nobody can force you to take a drug if you don't want it.
There are people who can be assisted with therapy. There are also people who need medications to keep depression or other issues in check. Anyone who says otherwise is either selling some snake-oil therapy or have been reading too many articles on FoxNews. These therapists or providers are usually anti-med because they are not MD's and cannot prescribe medications. They make their living by providing therapy, not drugs. People who find medication a help in alleviating depression and get their life back to normal take business away from them. Obviously, not all therapists are like this but some are fiercly anti-med, for the reasons noted.
Then there are always people who had issues with depression and went through therapy and it was helpful in tackling the issues that caused the underyling symptoms of depression. These types usually declare that if I didn't need them, nobody does. Their reasoning is totally unscientific or rational. Their thinking is black and white and they take a single case as statistical proof that meds are a crock and a conspiracy exists between the manufactuers and the psychiatrist to keep people hooked. These folks are also the most vocally anti-medication you will come acrosss. Ignore these people.
Then there are those such as myself, where medication has provided great benefits in quality of life enhancement and have found only minimal benefits via therapy in addressing issues with depression and anxiety. Sometimes, people in my situation might say therapy is worthless and a crock. Ignore these people too.
The issue of meds is not black and white. Everyone is different and nobody here can tell you that medications or therapy is the way to go. Consider all options, get second options if you are skeptical. But never let any one individual tell you that they know for a fact that this or that is the only method for you. This is a sure sign that you are either being marketed snake oil are talking to an ignorant fool or a parnoid NWO conspiracist.
“Perhaps, as some wit remarked, the best proof that there is Intelligent Life in Outer Space is the fact it hasn't come here. ”
--Arthur C Clarke