This is truly a human tragedy.
Without a doubt poorly trained officers did more harm than good. And FWIW the officer is further protected by his colleagues even if any wrong doing did take place.
Cases like this without a doubt are an example of a broken system. When a person becomes ill he or she is given a marry go round of drugs until one just happens to work, and if there is a problem just call the police. Unfortunately the police are the last ones equipped to deal with mentally ill people.
Criminal justice is a 200 year old concept drafted up at a time where it was believed all people broke the law because they are aware of what they are doing and punishment would force them to comply. Unfortunately that is not always the case. Many, many who brake the law are ill, and have no clue what they are doing or what is happening to them. Criminal justice still has trouble admitting that to be the case.
Officers today are very poorly trained. Training on how to handle illness is only a day or two, the course it just mediocre. If anything it just tells officers, "yaahhh, one or two of these bad guys might have a screw loose, just be aware of that" Officers still walk away with the notion that if a person is mentally ill just force them to comply. They are not taught verbal de-escalation, restraint or how to identify illness.
If anything they often escalate is situation trying to be intimidating, shouting, angry, hostile. Procedures that officers are led to believe help them and the person do nothing but escalate the situation. A good example is asking people to sit down and cross their legs in the event that if they try to run away an officer will see them trying to do so giving them time to respond. With a mentally ill person that is impossible to do. The officer does not understand the person is disobeying because the are ill, rather they see that as none compliance or getting ready to fight. The officer's trained response to the just escalates the situation out of control.
**TRIGGER WARNING**I have seen therapeutic restraint in clinics and hospitals. Compliance is not a priority. EVERYTHING is centered around both verbal / neuro linguistic de-escalation and therapeutic multi point restraint. Further an emphasis is placed on keeping hands away from vital points while using as little force as necessary to immobilize the patients. Limbs are placed in ergonomically difficult to move positions while the patient is rotated around making sure minimal injury takes place as the person is placed on soft surfaces. Injection is given where needed. During the entire procedure nurses as well as those doing the restraint make sure the patient is breathing. The mouth is kept open and tongue kept forward while any fluid is wiped up. An emphasis is made not to obstruct airways or neck arteries. Take down is
never done through the neck. "Choke holds" that police are trained to give are specifically avoided. If any vital signs raise a flag emergency aid is called upon to be administered immediately.
Since cops show up in batches I see no reason why a modified version of this can not be carried out. It takes training, but once learned deadly force is not needed.
I have witnessed a man break off a sharp metal leg from a table trying to stab others with it. A nurse half his size took him down, pulled the metal to the side and had him immobilized as other nurses took over. She had training that officers never get.
All officers are trained to do is yell, baton, tazor when someone is not listening and shoot when threatened. Police brutality will continue unless something changes.
***END TRIGGER***