Copy_Cat wrote:I think the mind can fully recover, The brain is just a thing but the mind is action like thoughts, beliefs dreams memories a whole long list of stuff that make us who we are.
The physical withdrawals are the brain trying to recover from damage I guess.
I agree in general. However, let me add some remarks: living 10 years in a "brain fog" will have an impact on your daily activities, feelings for that time and therefore, after stopping the fog, on your biography, which is part of who you are as an individual. Moreover, some effects such as tardive dyskenisia (unvoluntary movements) have an impact on how you feel in public etc., therefore may change your life and with this, your mind - aside from the fact that tardive dyskenisia often goes hand-in-hand with irreparable or only partially reversible cognitive impairment, which also impacts your mind. As the thread opener wrote they had been on their meds for only two months, I would say don't worry about these long-term side effects.
The physical withdrawals come from the fact that the brain likes to have its stuff balanced out. So if you decrease or increase neurotransmitter activity with drugs for a certain time, the brain starts adjusting by increasing or decreasing its own neurotransmitter production or the number of places in the neurons where these transmitters dock on. Therefore, it needs time to readapt to its "natural" state so this is why it is suggested that people don't stop their meds abruptly but better taper them off so your brain can adapt gradually. Neurotransmitters also have lots of impacts on the production of various hormones, other neurotransmitters and what have you not, and these do not only have an impact on your brain but on your whole body.
Which is why I don't buy into the "chemical imbalance causes your disease" metaphor in the sense that there is a constant physically caused imbalance or chemical deficiency comparable to a vitamin deficiency. There are indeed conditions, often genetic ones, where not enough or too much dopamin or whatever gets produced or broken down by the body, but this does not only impact the minds of the patients but also causes lots of physical problems, worse and more varied ones than those you experience in, e. g., major depression.
There is a condition, for example, where people have too much histamine in their system as they lack some kind of enzyme or stuff, I don't remember the exact name of the condition. They don't only have sleeping problems and feel wired all the time, but also have lots of allergy-like symptoms and gastro-internal problems, sweat a lot, have various metabolic abnormities in their blood results etc.
Things like this is the kind of problems that I would expect from a "chemical imbalance in your brain" cause. And when these people get treated with anti-histamines or the enzyme they lack, it's not only their mind that gets better - feeling more relaxed, being able to sleep well - but their physical problems go away too. In contrast, if you take an anti-histamine for a "simple" sleep disorder while having normal histamine levels, this can help for your symptom but will not have the other beneficial effects but instead, side-effects.
However, I can imagine that for some reasons and in some cases, before or during a psychiatric condition, specific functional parts of the brain may have changed in a way similar to what drugs do, i. e. the neurons having too many or not enough receptors of whatever in these parts of the brain. So antipsychotics, as "dirty" as they may be, might in some cases not only mask the problem but remede it, at the expence of creating chemical imbalances elsewhere in the brain and body which is why these drugs create metabolic disorders and what have you not. This does not mean, though, that the "chemical imbalance" is the CAUSE, as PTSD (Post-traumatic stress disorder) does also show up with changes in brain functionig, but here the cause is clearly a biographic/psychological one. It is more like a correlation, plus the chemistry and the mind influence one another. I think that depending on the symptoms and course of one's disorder etc., it may be possible to "unlearn" the disorder to a lesser or greater level via the change of amounts of receptors etc., however this may not be the case for everyone. So I think psych meds may be a help, but it's not the best or only solution for everyone especially not administered long-term. This is why I also basically agree to this statement:
ativan1 wrote:I feel ya. Sort of like "environment". I think most of all positivity is important. Too bad a lot of people think these disease are actually a chemical disorder. I mean the brain's chemistry can change by environment.
with the exception that for some people, the most important thing might not be positivity, but learning or re-learning to relax or whatever.
Razael wrote:I too have problems with spiritual death of antipsychotics, but only while on them,,,spiritual death is being seperated from love and joy of god living life with god which opens up to alchmical and evolutionary possablity...
I have noticed that the anti-psychotic I have been on for a couple of months had this kind of effects on me too, apart from the fact that I am a Christian and so the impact on my relationship with God was there too but I would describe it differently. This "spiritual death" decreased along with the decrease in dosage, therefore I prefer to call it "spiritual numbing". I also noticed that this effect is quite similar to when I took older types of anti-allergy tablets for my hay fever. Both meds block histamine receptors (the anti-psych drug blocks a couple of other receptors too). I still don't damn my allergy tablets, but it's a question of what is worse, my allergy and my urticaria or the "spiritual numbing" and sedation. When things get really bad a couple of days a year, I still choose to take them.