Well, I finally decided to comment again for the first time in almost 3 1/2 years. (My first comment was from September 5, 2012, and was like the 6th post in this thread.)
It's been interesting reading all the different ways that people approach their self-identified stuttering fetish. I seem to relate the most to what Emmanola and StutterFetishGal wrote (other than the obvious fact that they're both female and I'm male), in that I've always been ashamed to talk about this, even anonymously, and I feel kinda bad talking about my fetish to actual stutterers. I also don't feel like it would be right to talk to a stutterer just to hear them stutter. (Not that there's anything wrong with those in this thread who have requested to talk to stutterers; this is just just how I feel.) So instead, I secretly watch videos of women stuttering. Even then, I sometimes feel bad about it, because these are real people who have no idea I'm watching them in that way. But that doesn't stop the fact that I get extremely turned on for whatever reason.
I'm also 44, and I've had this for as long as I can remember.