Yes, that's what I tried to tell my friend. There's a difference between talking about suicide and actually planning to do it. When a therapist considers whether a person is actually suicidal they can't (shouldn't) act unless the person is in imminent danger of carrying out the act.
The problem was that my friend had already been place in protective custody, before, just for mentioning it. The practitioner asked whether my friend felt like committing suicide and they said, "Well...sometimes...I guess..." and the person pulled the trigger. The next thing you know, the cops were at their door.
When my friend and I visited the new therapist, I knew this. Even before we went there, my friend told me that they were afraid of being committed, again. During that first session, the therapist asked if there were any questions. That's when I brought it up. When the therapist replied with a pat answer, I instantly knew that it was all over. There would be no way my friend would ever trust that therapist!
I am still trying to help my friend get therapy. For myself, too. Unfortunately, in the area where we live, there aren't many options outside of the standard Social Services organizations but they aren't very good, as I have said. I had a therapist from the same place, before. I went for a while but the people there are more concerned with taking care of the indigent, homeless or people with severe conditions. "Normal" people aren't very high on their list of priorities. The therapist I was seeing had to cancel our appointment, one time, because of an emergency situation with another patient.
There are private therapists in this area but our insurance doesn't cover more than a few visits before you have to pay out of pocket. When you live paycheck to paycheck, like I do, private therapists just aren't an option.
I have been to AA, Al-Anon and NA meetings before. They were somewhat helpful but it's hard to talk about the things I need to talk about in places like that. When you start telling stories about watching your mother kick a drunk out of a bar, the room gets
really quiet. Most people think I'm making these things up. Self-help groups like Al-Anon just aren't the venue for talk like that. Y'know?
Just recently, a couple-few weeks ago, some friends at work were talking about the 'Harry Potter' movies where Harry, Ron and Hermione were sitting in Hogsmeade pub, drinking butterbeer. The question was whether butterbeer was alcoholic or not.
First off, let's just make it clear that we're talking about fiction. Harry Potter doesn't really exist, except in books and movies. There isn't really such a thing as butterbeer. I'm only talking about the social aspects of such a scene in a movie.
Harry Potter and his friends are ADOLESCENTS! They can't be much older than high school age. At best, they would be college freshmen or sophomores. It doesn't matter whether butterbeer would be alcoholic or not. Teenagers should not be going to pubs! PERIOD!
Also, I am aware that my upbringing colors my outlook. Yes, I grew up in a tough place. I understand that other people don't see things with a jaundiced eye, as I do.
To me scenes from movies, like this, only highlight the disconnect between people's perceptions and reality. Bars are places where people go to drink, smoke and cheat on their spouses. The concepts of socialization and fun that we see in movies is nothing more than a pipe dream.
I moved out of the bar where I grew up when I returned home from college. The place has been sold off and I haven't been back there for forty years but the place still haunts me.
Just the ways that a kid learns to interact with others can poison the rest of their life.
I, sometimes, get upset at the idyllic way that people seem to think about bars, pubs, nightclubs and the like. Sure, for adults, it can be like that if you want it to be. You go there, have a couple of drinks, shoot the bull for a while. You meet people, you have fun but, afterward, you go home. If the place is too seedy for your taste, you don't have to go back. You can find some other place that's more to your liking. For a kid, what happens when they CAN'T LEAVE?! The bar is your home! You're trapped there!
When your mother is behind the bar, slinging brewskies, as guys are standing three deep at the rail, shouting "Gimme' a beer" and your father is outside, in the back seat of a car with the waitress who should be inside, helping, your attitude changes.
Let me make it crystal clear... This is not just about alcohol. Alcohol, I understand. I don't drink very much, anymore because, like I said, me and Ol' John Barleycorn see things eye to eye. On the rare occasions when I do drink, I'm basically "one and done."
I'm talking about the warped sense of reality that comes with working and living in bars, in places where people go to drink and act like A-holes.
Growing up around alcohol certainly is a problem but the atmosphere that pervades a place like that is much more damaging to a kid's sense of self.